google-site-verification: google5ae98130f18ad244.html

Sunday, December 16, 2018
Text Size

Residential Real Estate

Aug. 7 – BREAKING: Leaders Delay Vote on ‘City of Skidaway Island’ Over Technical Issues; But Opposition Was Growing

Category: Residential Real Estate

By Lou Phelps, Savannah Business Journal

August 7, 2018 – About a month ago, Mike Vaquer, a long-time resident of The Landings on Skidaway Island, and a registered lobbyist in the State of Georgia, decided there were just too many questions regarding the upcoming vote in the November General Election regarding whether residents wanted to support the creation of a new municipality on Skidaway Island – The City of Skidaway Island.

Along with his wife Jean McRae, also a registered lobbyist in Georgia, they launched a Facebook campaign ‘Skiddy City – NOT’ and began posting questions, answers and facts they saw, including: technical problems with the legislation itself;  voter registration information problems; revenue and expense projections they believed were inaccurate; property tax questions; and other legal and management issues involved in running a city that they believed the leadership behind the effort had not addressed in the information provided to residents and property owners.

It looks like their effort, along with a growing opposition to incorporating the area into what would have been Chatham County’s ninth municipality, has resulted in issue coming off the November ballot.

This afternoon, Savannah media received the following press release from State. Rep. Jesse Petrea and State Senator Ben Watson, who represent all of the voters on Skidaway Island, including those outside the gates of The Landings, and who filed the bill in the Georgia General Assembly to put the question on the ballot.

Their joint statement reads:

“As part of the ongoing due diligence efforts in preparation for the vote to create the City of Skidaway Island, the Incorporation Steering Committee recently discovered a drafting error in the proposed Charter which could have been interpreted to exempt all residential property from property taxes.  The Georgia Office of Legislative Counsel confirmed that the legislature’s attorney made a typographical error when drafting the bill and has advised postponing the referendum in order to clarify the enabling legislation when the General Assembly goes back in session. 

As such, on August 6, 2018, we, Representative Jesse Petrea and Senator Ben Watson, sent a letter to the Chatham County Elections Superintendent requesting that the Elections Board postpone the advertisement which would have placed on the November ballot the referendum that would have created the new City of Skidaway Island.  While House Bill 618 originally projected the referendum would appear on the local ballot on the November 6, 2018 General Election, the legislative language intentionally allowed for a flexible date. This was to allow the necessary due diligence prior to the referendum.  Accordingly, as the sponsors of this enabling legislation, we requested that the measure be postponed to an eligible election date in 2019 in order to allow us to correct the typographical error and to potentially make additional improvements to the Charter including but not limited to:

1. Adding a voter referendum requirement prior to tax increases.

One of the main purposes in creating the new City of Skidaway Island is to control the growth of property taxes.  In a recent survey of Skidaway Island residents, a number of persons expressed concern and skepticism that sufficient controls exist to discourage or prevent a newly created government from raising taxes.  As such, we would like to add an additional provision to the proposed Charter that would require a local referendum prior to the City Council increasing the millage rate.  This is a tool that has been utilized by a number of new cities including Sandy Springs, John’s Creek, Milton, Dunwoody, Peachtree Corners, Brookhaven, LaVista Hills, Tucker and others.  While under the municipal powers of home rule, a municipality will always retain the ability to increase taxes regardless of voter approval, we feel this additional step in the process will increase the opportunity for the voters to voice their concern and will discourage tax increases as it has done in the municipalities which have adopted this measure. 


2.  Further reduce the proposed starting millage rate and cap -  As proposed in the original draft charter, the starting millage rate for City of Skidaway Island property taxes is capped at 4.13 mills.  Revenue collections as analyzed by both the Georgia State University Andrew Young School of Public Policy and by the Skidaway Island Incorporation Steering Committee verified that this millage rate would indeed fully fund the needs of the new municipality.  Additionally, Chatham County subsequently increased the millage rate for the Special Services District to 4.99 mills, thus using the 4.13 millage rate in the Charter accomplished an immediate roll back of taxes for Skidaway Island property owners.  Based on the due diligence of the local steering committee and in consultation with subject matter experts, it has been determined that other revenue sources may potentially provide more revenue than originally estimated.  If this is the case, then it may be possible to further reduce the property tax millage rate and cap it at an amount lower than 4.13 mills, further reducing the tax burden on Skidaway Island property owners.  Additional time is needed to conservatively determine if a further reduction is feasible and prudent. 


3.  Improve Homestead Exemptions - Maintaining all existing Chatham County homestead exemptions as well as the Stephens-Day property tax valuation freeze is a top priority for the creation of the City of Skidaway Island.  In addition to strengthening the Charter language, it may be possible to potentially increase the homestead exemptions for veterans, veterans’ surviving spouses and some senior citizens.  We would like to take time to further investigate these options and determine their fiscal impact on the proposed budget. 


4.  Clarify flood insurance matters - Avoidance of the potential short-term loss of the flood insurance discount received by some home owners is a matter that requires continued investigation.  To date, conflicting information has been received from state and federal agencies concerning the “grace period” for a newly created municipality.  Additional time is needed to work with subject matter experts and Congressman Buddy Carter to gain clarity on this matter.  This will also allow time for coordination between local state and federal officials to ensure a smooth transition to a new municipal flood management program.


Their statement concludes by saying, “The creation of a new municipality is a matter that should be carefully considered, debated and evaluated.   It is a matter that deserves an abundance of caution.  Based on the feedback received from the Incorporation Steering Committee, Skidaway Island residents, and legislative counsel, additional time is needed to further research the above areas and to clarify the proposed Charter during the 2019 Georgia General Assembly session.   While the matter will not appear on the local ballot this November, Island residents will still have the opportunity to vote on the creation of the City of Skidaway Island once these matters are addressed.”

Mike Vaquer’s response on hearing about the announcement: “I am, for once in my life, absolutely speechless. I think they have addressed a number of issues of concern, but there are several other issues that are very problematic within the proposed Charter itself, so basically, they will be looking at starting the process over again.”

“I think it will be very interesting to see how the Committee will respond, based on increased scrutiny and how and why new cities are being formed in Georgia,” he added. Both Mike and Jean participate in the drafting of legislation for their clients.

“We have said all along that this legislation is flawed on many fronts, and we sincerely hope that all parties decide that neither Chatham County nor the residents of Skidaway Island need this city,” he stated.

“For example, regarding language about changing the millage rate cap, any increase in a ‘Charter Cap’ must be changed by the Legislature. Without the legislation being changed, regardless of what the voters say, the cap can’t be changed locally. That means any such bill would have to be what is termed ‘local legislation.’  That would throw our future fate into the hands of our Chatham County delegation, when we have no idea who will be part of that delegation in the future, nor the rules by which that delegation operates,” Vaquer explained.

“And, by pushing this legislation out (to a vote sometime in 2019) they would block any new city for Skidaway Island from participating in the upcoming SLOST 7 process,” he added, “which starts in January.”

“In addition, we continue to contend that the legislation for the proposed city did not meet the requirements in state law for developed land, in order to even make a city,” he concluded.  

Overall Rating (0)

0 out of 5 stars

Leave your comments

Post comment as a guest

0 / 300 Character restriction
Your text should be in between 10-300 characters
Your comments are subjected to administrator's moderation.
terms and condition.
    • No comments found
    CLICK to SUBSCRIBE and Support Great Journalism!

    Follow Us!


    Komento Activities

    Guest - Maria Johnson Pleming - Commented on Oct. 25 - Department of Biolog... in Joomla Article
    So happy to know the Millen Fish Hatchery will be recognized for the incredible system. Mr uncle Dav...
    Guest - Karin Mcgruder - Commented on June 4 - Foram Group Announces... in Joomla Article
    Are there any updates on this project?and when will the first apartments be available?
    Guest - Hart Williford - Commented on June 28 - Savannah Music Festi... in Joomla Article
    Rob will be missed by the entire Savannah Community, he built the Savannah Music Festival to worldwi...
    Guest - Daryl Stair - Commented on Oct. 16 - Sonesta Resort Hilto... in Joomla Article
    Do you have to be a paying guest to use the Tesla charger?
    Guest - JR Lee - Commented on MPC approves plan for new Walm... in Joomla Article
    Great, another complex to attract Savannah's finest entitlement minded individuals. Another complex ...
    Guest - Jack - Commented on Aug. 23 - Phelps on Politics -... in Joomla Article
    "Goose that laid the golden EYE? You're right, that is hard to argue with.
    Guest - Robin Sherman - Commented on Jan. 4 – COMMENTARY: New Year... in Joomla Article
    Excellent post, Ms. Phelps. Effective government can only occur when the public is informed. Transpa...
    Guest - Tao of Me - Commented on Why is Memorial Hospital Being... in Joomla Article
    They aren't telling Memorial employees anything about this. A recent survey of the facilities by Nic...
    Guest - Genie Brazzeal - Commented on Feb. 24 – Lawyer and former Al... in Joomla Article
    Thank you, Mr. Bordeaux! Bring some honesty to this court. No more winking like I experienced.
    Guest - Karl - Commented on Feb. 25 - Memorial Hospital’s ... in Joomla Article
    Good article. Has a lot of information that is very difficult for "team members"(employees) to find....
    Guest - Susan Worthington - Commented on May 13 – UPDATED 11:39 a.m. HC... in Joomla Article
    In 1953 there was not such a thing as a trauma or neonatal program. The need for Neonatal Services ...
    Guest - Linda Dominy - Commented on June 8 – EDITORIAL: Immediate ... in Joomla Article
    As a clinical team member this makes me sad and it would never happen. We can argue politics all day...
    Guest - Judy - Commented on Savannah’s Title Max Bankruptc... in Joomla Article
    How Tracy Young was allowed to file for bankruptcy or chapter 11 is amazing. Title Max should be ch...
    Guest - Samantha Claar - Commented on Aug. 7 - COMMENTARY: Je suis “... in Joomla Article
    Pertinent questions that deserve real answers. If upper management - appointed and elected - can't ...
    Guest - Ken - Commented on Aug. 6 - Dept. of Labor propos... in Joomla Article
    Is this state or federal?
    Coastal Empire News
    Headquarters: 35 Barnard St., Suite 300, Savannah, GA. 31401.
    Tel: 912-388-4692 | Hours: 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.